中文体育类核心期刊

中国人文社会科学期刊AMI综合评价(A刊)核心期刊

《中文社会科学引文索引》(CSSCI)来源期刊

美国《剑桥科学文摘》(CSA)收录期刊

中国高校百佳科技期刊

妨害兴奋剂管理罪的合体系性解释

System Interpretation of Crime of Obstructing Doping Management

  • 摘要: 法益的辨识是对具体罪名进行解释的必要前提。通过对既有的相关反兴奋剂文献的梳理总结以及根据妨害兴奋剂管理罪的体系定位,认为:妨害兴奋剂管理罪的保护法益包括赛事公平性、国家声誉以及健康权,其中健康权又包括使用兴奋剂运动员自身的健康权、兴奋剂滥用可能会危害的整个运动员群体的健康权以及抽象的国民健康权。对于侵害以上所有法益的行为应重点打击,而对只侵害部分法益的行为应限制本罪的适用。合体系性解释是理解该刑法规范的重要路径。具体构成要素的理解与适用:体育竞赛应限于《体育法》中的竞技体育,而不包括学校体育和社会体育,且应分别从比赛层级、影响力方面界定国内、国际重大体育竞赛;引诱、教唆、欺骗以及组织、强迫行为同样需要对赛事性质主观明知,否则阻却主观故意;需要在区分不同行为类型的前提下把握“情节严重”的应有内涵。

     

    Abstract: The identification of legal interests is a necessary prerequisite for the interpretation of specific charges. By summarizing the existing relevant anti-doping literature and the positioning for crime of obstructing doping management, it is believed that the legal interests of this crime include the fairness of the competition, the reputation of the country and the right to health, among which the right to health includes the right to the health of the doping athletes themselves, the right to the health of the whole group of athletes that may be infringed by the abuse of doping, and the abstract right to national health. For those behaviors that infringe all the above legal interests, severe punishment should be offered; while the application of this crime will be restricted for those behaviors that infringe only part of the legal interests. Systematic interpretation is an important way to understand this criminal law norms. For understanding and application of specific constituent elements, the sports competition should be limited to competitive sports in the Sports Law, not including school sports and social sports. For defining major domestic and international sports competitions, it should be defined from the aspects of competition levels and influences. As for the behaviors like luring, abetting, deceiving and organizing and compelling, the elements of subjective knowledge are also needed; otherwise, they should be negated. The connotation of "serious circumstance"should be clarified under the premise of distinguishing different types of behaviors.

     

/

返回文章
返回